Which mascara wins?

I tried two Loreal mascaras:
1. Telescopic (regular in gold tube).
2. Volume Shocking

Which one do you like better - or neither?

Picture below - no mascara (sorry no makeup either)



Volume Shocking


Telescopic



Comparison of both - please click to see a larger view


I think Volume Shocking gave slightly longer and fuller lashes, but clumped them like crazy (think Twiggy). What do you guys think?